Abstract Details

Title: Thinking about occupation-response & exposure-response relationships: doubt science & mesothelioma
Authors: Kay Teschke
Session: Renewed questions on asbestos and lung health - St. David, 17 Oct 2016, 2:10 PM - 3:10 PM

Background & Objectives

In 1997, I wrote a paper on mesothelioma that estimated relative risks for a variety of occupations, including vehicle and brake repair. It has been regularly used in litigation to fight claims of people who had done such work. A new meta-analysis refers to our paper in a way that suggests its continuing use in this way.

Methods

The talk will address two questions:

Are studies of motor vehicle and brake repair activities appropriate ways to examine the risks of mesothelioma from chrysotile exposure?

Is it appropriate to require evidence of elevated associations between an occupation and a disease to ascertain whether someone incurred the disease as a result of exposures in that occupation?

Results

It may be reasonable to study jobs or tasks to investigate whether chrysotile asbestos causes mesothelioma, but note that the jobs or tasks are being used as surrogates of chrysotile exposure. It is important to consider whether they are good surrogates. Some occupations are synonymous with extensive exposure to certain agents. For example, it would be an exceptional asbestos insulator without daily high exposure to amphibole asbestos. Many jobs have much more variable exposures so that any true exposure-response relationship will be attenuated or not observable when examined instead via an occupation-response analysis.

Requiring that every person who has a disease arising from workplace exposure provide epidemiological evidence that their specific job has an elevated risk of that disease is not scientifically defensible. First, it is impossible to study every occupation-disease relationship. Even where a job has been studied, the potential for variable exposures within a job to dilute the relationship is probable for many jobs, and would prevent a person with high exposures from having their occupational disease recognized, simply because others in the same job were not similarly exposed. The question is whether the exposure caused the disease. A job cannot cause disease, its exposures may.   

 

Conclusions

It is vital to carefully delineate the questions that must be answered in considering occupational disease claims. Doubt science lives in occupational health.