Background & Objectives This study assessed cross-jurisdictional differences in work disability duration in three Canadian provinces: British Columbia (BC), Manitoba (MB) and Ontario (ON) for the years 2007 to 2011.
Methods Comparable cohorts of injured workers in each of the three provinces were created using individual-level claims data. Comparisons were made on total disability days paid per 1,000 standardized claims by summing the cumulative number of disability days paid post injury at six months, six months to one year and one year overall. Analysis was conducted by sector (e.g. construction and health care), occupation (e.g. labourers and registered nurses) and injury type (e.g. strain and non-strain). Results The BC, MB and ON cohorts comprised of 258,247, 70,221 and 295,934 claims respectively. Across all injuries and all occupations the number of disability days paid per 1000 claims over one-year post injury was 37,449, 28,780 and 30,637 in BC, MB and ON. By sector, the mean number of disability days paid in healthcare was markedly lower in Ontario (BC: 42.6; MB: 39.9; ON: 23.6), while the mean number of days paid in construction was highest in ON and lowest in MB (BC: 43.8; MB: 35.3; ON: 51.4). By sector and occupation, for nurses within healthcare, ON further diverged from BC and MB (BC: 41.2; MB: 42.4; ON: 18.3), while the mean number of days paid for labourers within construction was highest in ON and lowest in MB (BC: 40.1; MB: 33.6; ON: 51.7). In trends over time across all industries, disability duration levels were constant in MB, increasing in BC, and decreasing in ON. Conclusions Large differences in cumulative number of disability days paid were observed across jurisdictions and sector. Results indicate that jurisdiction has a marked effect on duration of work-disability by injury type, sector and occupation across Canadian provinces which may relate to differences in policies and approaches to work disability management.
|