Background & Objectives An effective strike is one that demonstrates that without the striking employees the work being done by the employer will be ineffective. Commonly strikes occur by employees who are part of a union such as Nurses. In Canada, health-care is highly unionized, with 83% of nurses belonging to a union (Briskin, 2012). During the implementation of an online survey of hospital employees at four Canada health districts, the nurses in one of the four districts commenced a legal strike. After a few weeks, the provincial government passed back-to-work legislation, ending the strike. The survey was suspended for the duration of the strike and recommenced when the employees returned to work. This event created a quasi-experimental study in which the participants in the striking district were the intervention group and those in the other three districts were the controls. The objective of the analysis was to examine the impact of the strike on collegial relationships. Methods Participating organizations were four healthcare districts in Eastern Canada. Participants included first-line managers (FLMs; N=157) and frontline staff (N=1624). Burnout was measured with the 16-item Maslach Burnout Inventory—General Scale (MBI—GS) assessing exhaustion, cynicism, and efficacy. Incivility was measured with the 12-item Straightforward Incivility Scale (Leiter & Day, 2013) that included three subscales: supervisor, coworker, and instigated incivility. Workgroup Civility was measured with the 8-item CREW civility scale (Osatuke et al, 2009). Three items from a scale developed by Edmondson (1999) measured psychological safety. Coworker trust and supervisor trust were each measured with three items from the trust subscale developed by Cook and Wall (1980). Results Overall the strike was associated with a decrease in collegiality. The change from before to after the strike was especially evident for first line managers. Those in the striking health district reported an increase in coworker incivility and subordinate incivility after the back-to-work process. The control health districts reported a steady level of civility and incivility over this period. Conclusions Results are discussed in the context of collegiality in the context of labor disputes with consideration of implications for work engagement and burnout.
|