Background & Objectives This research project focuses on a systematic analysis of 10 Occupational Health & Safety (OHS) commissioned reports from Canada, New Zealand, the United States, Australia, and the United Kingdom, spanning from 1967 to 2015. The objective is to identify commonalities and differences in the key recommendations across the identified reports over the 48-year timeframe, from the first commissioned report to the most recent mining review. This thematic analysis will provide a longitudinal perspective of the recommendations around: health and safety hazards, the role of technology, emergency preparedness and mine rescue, worker training, regulating bodies, and management/leadership. This paper will focus primarily on the issue of worker fatigue. The purpose was to describe how worker fatigue was identified and discussed as an occupational hazard over the past 50 years, in OHS commissioned reports. Methods The systematic analysis was undertaken in two stages. First the text mining software Leximancer was utilized to analyze the content of each report through semantic extraction of dominant themes, followed by relational extraction that involved the mapping of thematic relationships against each other. In the second stage, the researchers immersed themselves within the themes identified to fully understand the relationships and ensure proper interpretation. Results Fatigue, was discussed in 4 of the OHS reports; however, the context of the discussion was different in each case. In 1976 fatigue was linked to high noise levels, in 1997 fatigue was linked to 12-hour work shifts, in 2012 fatigue was linked to worker training, and in 2015 fatigue was highlighted as a major risk factor that had the potential to contribute to injury. The 2015 report indicated that research is needed to address fatigue through the development of a proactive risk management strategy. Additional findings relating international recommendations and situating Ontario within these will be presented with visual relationship maps. Conclusions The results of this analysis illustrate that the same hazards continue to be identified and similar recommendations to mitigate the hazard often appear in more than one report. This trend suggests that the hazards are not being adequately addressed, regardless of time or country involved.
|