Abstract Details

Title: Occupational health and safety inspection processes: challenges of addressing non-standard employment
Authors: Ellen MacEachen; Saunders Ron; Katherine Lippel; Sarah Sanford
Session: Health considerations for vulnerable work and workforces - St. David, 17 Oct 2016, 10:15 AM - 11:45 AM

Background & Objectives

In today’s economy, jobs are increasingly non-standard and insecure. Lewchuk’s 2013 survey of workers in Southern Ontario found that only half of the sample of working age adults were in standard full-time jobs. Canadian workers are ever more engaged in short-term contracts directly with firms or via temporary employment agencies or are self-employed. The objective of this study was to examine how occupational health and safety (OHS) inspectors’ work is organised, how inspectors recognise and address poor work conditions in relation to non-standard forms of employment, and how the OHS inspection process can be adapted to the needs of non-standard workers and employers.

Methods

In-depth interviews were conducted in 2013 with 26 Ontario OHS inspectors, OHS operational managers and OHS policy makers. Interviews were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim, and coded. Data included field notes, interview transcripts, and relevant policy and institutional documents. An institutional ethnographic analysis was conducted to identify how inspectors understand and act on non-standard work hazards and key organisational structures shaping inspectors’ work.

Results

The study identified three key challenges to inspectors’ ability to address work hazards in non-standard employment environments. First, targeting and inspection processes are geared to traditional stakeholders and known hazards. Workplaces with mostly non-standard employment and few reported accidents are not apparent. Second, when inspectors do identify OHS problems in these workplaces it is difficult for them to collect evidence that meets standards needed for prosecution, due to problems such as workers who are fearful to speak up, worker deaths off site, fragmented paper trails and complex corporate identities that obscure who is the employer. Third, how inspectors are organised compounds some of these challenges. Points systems to monitor inspector work progress, staff shortages and other work conditions effectively limit inspectors’ focus to relatively straightforward and prosecutable OHS events.

Conclusions

 Non-standard workers and workplaces appear to be relatively invisible in Ontario’s inspection system.  Adjustments to workplace inspection targeting processes and inspectors work organisation may be starting points for new strategies needed to support inspectors to maneuver in the context of growing non-standard employment conditions.