Abstract Details

Title: What kinds of work disability program design issues are researchers focusing on in cause-based versus comprehensive work disability systems?
Authors: Ellen MacEachen; Sharanya Varatharajan; Brondon Du; Emma Bartel; Emile Tompa; Kerstin Ekberg; Agnieszka Kosny; Ivana Petricone
Session: Poster Session - Colony Ballroom, 16 Oct 2016, 5:30 PM - 7:00 PM

Background & Objectives

Our scoping review of literature on work reintegration programs after injury or illness yielded a large dataset that was then organised by thematic foci. Our objective was to identify what return-to-work (RTW) program design issues were raised in jurisdictions with cause-based work disability systems versus comprehensive (non-cause-based) work disability systems.

Methods

 A systematic literature search was conducted of 4 key data bases, yielding 9570 English language articles published 2000 to 2014. Titles and abstracts were reviewed to include articles that were peer reviewed and focused on state legislation, policy or programs on work reintegration and/or income support after injury or illness. Our final sample of 724 articles was sorted into 6 themes, including ‘program design and adequacy’, and into program types, including ‘return to work’. Intersecting ‘program design and adequacy’ and ‘return to work’ articles were identified (93) and sorted into three categories:  Workplace-level (RTW issues), insurer-level (claim filing and compensation issues) and state-level (law and policy issues).

Results

The 93 articles spanned 17 countries.  Of these, 70 focused on countries with cause-based systems (e.g. North America, Australia) and 19 on countries with comprehensive systems (e.g. most of Europe); 4 spanned both systems.  Main workplace level issues raised in cause-based systems were design of disability management systems and the impact of work type or specific health conditions on RTW; comprehensive system articles mostly addressed workers’ struggle with RTW. Main insurer level issues raised in cause-based system articles were roadblocks in injury and claim reporting, trust between workers and the RTW system, and procedural fairness; the few comprehensive system articles addressed injury reporting road blocks. State level cause-based articles focused on the adequacy of coverage provided by laws and policy; the few comprehensive system articles addressed coordination of key players.

Conclusions

This scoping review identifies the kinds of RTW program design and adequacy issues being researched in cause-based versus comprehensive work disability systems. Articles from cause-based systems mostly addressed issues at the insurer and state level. Articles from comprehensive systems had a relative focus on workplace-level issues.