Abstract Details

Title: Conflicting Expectations about Disclosure of Accommodation Needs Between Employers and Workers with Fibromyalgia
Authors: Margaret Oldfield; Ellen MacEachen; Margaret MacNeill; Bonnie Kirsh
Session: Emerging topics in Return to Work - St. Patrick, 17 Oct 2016, 10:15 AM - 11:45 AM

Background & Objectives

Employees and job applicants with disabilities are encouraged to disclose their accommodation needs. Work-accommodation policy often assumes that disclosure is unproblematic. For employees impaired by invisible chronic illnesses such as fibromyalgia, disclosure can be risky, depending on job precariousness and workplace relationships. Even among applicants with visible impairments, disclosure during the hiring process sharply reduces hiring success. Encouragement to disclose assumes that accommodation requests are granted; yet, one-third are refused. Unsurprisingly, 45% of Canadian employees with disabilities do not seek accommodations they need. This presentation explores conflicting expectations between (a) work-accommodation policy, and by extension employers, that workers will disclose accommodation needs and (b) the unwillingness of workers with fibromyalgia to disclose.

Methods

A conceptual framework comprising (a) a modified version of the social model of disability that incorporates impairments, (b) stigma as a social process, and (c) workplace identity management guided our study of how women with fibromyalgia remain employed. Critical discourse methodology guided analysis of 22 interviews with related groups of participants: women with fibromyalgia, their family members, and co-workers or supervisors. Four additional interviews with managers unrelated to the women and one union representative supplemented the triads. Four analytical strategies were used to interpret the data across and within the groups: coding for data management, code summaries, narrative summaries, and relationship mapping.


Results

We observed a conflict between employees’ and managers’ views on whether and when employees should disclose accommodation needs. In general, supervisors and human-resources managers wanted employees to disclose their needs as soon as possible, ideally during interviews. Doing otherwise, some felt, was dishonest. On the other hand, employees were unwilling to disclose during interviews and, instead, disclosed selectively at different times, to different people, giving different information, depending on workplace relationships and related disclosure risks. Some employees pretested disclosure with co-workers who ‘got’ chronic illness, because they had it or knew someone who did.

Conclusions

To improve job retention of employees with chronic illnesses, policy-makers, disability managers, human-resource professionals, and supervisors need to better understand why many workers do not disclose their accommodation needs as soon as possible – if at all.