Abstract Details

Title: Gender differences in detailed return-to-work trajectories following a workers’ compensation claim for musculoskeletal injury
Authors: Mieke Koehoorn; Christopher McLeod; Lillian Tamburic; Sheilah Hogg-Johnson; Katherine Lippel
Session: Emerging topics in Return to Work - St. Patrick, 17 Oct 2016, 10:15 AM - 11:45 AM

Background & Objectives

Research on occupational injuries has relied on cessation of time-loss workers’ compensation benefits as a primary return-to-work outcome, despite return-to-work being a complex and graduated process. The objective of this presentation is to describe more detailed return-to-work trajectories using workers’ compensation calendar event data (i.e. dates for off work, modified hours/duties, full return-to-work, non return-to-work), and to investigate differences in return-to-work outcomes by gender.

Methods

Data for three cohorts of workers defined by musculoskeletal injury were extracted from time-loss workers’ compensation claims in British Columbia with an injury date in 2009 or 2010: (1) back strains (n=22,867); (2) fractures/dislocations (n=5,590); and (3) soft tissue disorders (n=2,711). Injured workers were followed for one-year post injury date for return-to-work events, stratified by gender.

Results

The majority of all three musculoskeletal injury cohorts had a post injury trajectory of time off work followed by full return-to-work (ranging from 52% to 59%), usually within the first 30 days. The second most common trajectory following injury was a period off work, followed by modified work and then full return-to-work (20% to 23%), also usually within the first 30 days. Men were more likely than women to have sustained, full return-to-work without episodes off work (63% versus 54% for back strains; 55% versus 45% for dislocations/fractures; and 58% versus 46% for soft tissue disorders), while women were more likely to participate in modified work as part of their return-to-work trajectory (38% versus 28% for back strains; 42% versus 29% for soft tissue disorders; and 44% versus 29% for fractures/dislocations). These gender differences persisted within the same occupational group.

Conclusions

Men were more likely than women to return to work within the first 30 days of a work-related musculoskeletal injury and less likely to have episodic trajectories of on/off work, adjusted for occupation. Women were more likely to participate in modified work than men, which may provide a partial explanation for observed longer disability durations among women if these benefit days are considered time loss as part of a compensation claim.