Background & Objectives The impact of work-life balance on retention has drawn a lot of attention in health human resources research. The mounting evidence almost exclusively focuses on health care providers in practice and offers little insight into the influence it may have on the experiences and retention of trainees – students enrolled in professional programs. The goal of our research is to examine how the perceptions about work-life balance in the midwifery profession shape the experiences of midwifery students in education programs in Ontario. Specifically, we explore: - What perceptions do students hold about the ability to maintain work-life balance in the profession of midwifery?
- How do these perceptions shape students’ educational experiences?
- What is the impact of these perceptions on students’ intention to stay in the program and the profession?
Methods The paper is based on a qualitative analysis of 19 semi-structured interviews with upper-level students enrolled in midwifery education programs in Ontario. The interviews were analyzed using Charmaz’s (2003) guidelines. Results Students believed that the unpredictable nature of midwifery practice makes it hard to maintain work-life balance. They saw clinical practicums as a particularly challenging time for managing any kind of balance between their personal and professional lives. The confounding pressures to attend the required number of births and to sufficiently impress the preceptor placed students in a situation where they felt that they had to sacrifice their personal wellbeing and led some to consider leaving the program. Students believed that once registered as a midwife, they would have more control over their work and, therefore, would have better chance of finding work-life balance. Some openly rejected the “old school” ideology of midwifery as being built on a willingness of midwives to sacrifice their personal life and advocated for a “new” midwifery that recognizes the rights of practitioners alongside the rights of clients. Conclusions Professional ideology shapes the perceptions of work-life balance but it may also undergo a generational change under the pressure from newly trained practitioners. More research is needed into the impact work-life balance may have on trainees – students in health professions.
|