Background & Objectives Annual injury rates amongst Ontario FireRangers are high compared to other occupations and fatigue is cited as a potential contributing factor. A pilot study was conducted during the 2014 fire season, wherein field measurements of sleep quality and quantity were collected to gauge FireRanger sleep profiles. Methods Sleep measures were collected from 23 male, wildland FireRangers from a northern Ontario base using wActiSleep-BT monitors. Sleep quality and quantity were partitioned according to: 1) non-fire versus fire work; and 2) fire deployment characteristics including: i) Shift length of 10-12 hours versus >12 hours, ii) Shift start times at 5-6:30 AM versus >6:30 AM and iii) consecutive work periods (CWP) from 1-3 days, 4-7 days and >7 days. Results (SE=Sleep Efficiency ± standard deviation (%), TST=Total Sleep Time ± standard deviation (minutes)) Non-Fire/Fire: Sleep scores for non-fire (SE=85.7±7.9, TST=371.6±58.1) and fire deployments (SE=86.1±10.7, TST=362.7±63.4) were similar. Separating fire deployments as initial attacks (SE=75.6±19.2, TST=287.2±69.3) or project fires (SE=87.6±7.9, TST=373.4±55.1) revealed a trend that sleep quality and quantity was lower for initial attack deployments. Fire Deployment Shift Length and Start Time: Sleep profiles for shifts lasting 10-12 hours (SE=86.6±12.0, TST=361.4±65.1) and for longer shifts (>12 hours) (SE=85.7±9.2, TST=366.7±61.2) were found to be similar. Sleep scores for early start times (5-6:30 AM) (SE=85.2±13.7, TST=335.9±81.1) and moderately early start times (>6:30 AM) (SE=86.4±9.4, TST=372.3±53.1) show that earlier starts, result in shortened TST (i.e. 36 fewer minutes sleep). Project Fire - CWP: Sleep scores for 1-3 day CWP (SE=90.1±6.7, TST=367.4±63.9), for 4-7 day (SE=87.2±7.7, TST=364.6±46.9) and for >7 days (SE=86.6±8.6, TST=385.1±56.0) reflect a trend of 6-6.5 hours of TST with a slight decline in SE (90.1 to 86.6%) as CWP lengthens. Conclusions These scores suggest that many FireRangers are near the threshold of inadequate sleep (i.e. SE≤85% and TST<7hours), even during non-fire work. This suggests these FireRangers may be regularly sleep deprived, possibly increasing physical/mental fatigue at work. These data also suggest that sleep is suboptimal, regardless of shift length, and particularly with early shift start times. Educational interventions should focus on sleep hygiene practices, particularly for non-fire and initial attack fire deployments. Policy changes could target shift start times.
|