Abstract Details

Title: Program evaluation of work disability programs: what has been done over the past 15 years?
Authors: Bronson Du; Ellen MacEachen; Emma Bartel; Emile Tompa; Agnieszka Kosny; Kerstin Ekberg; Ivana Petricone; Jackie Stapleton
Session: The Organizational level: disability and occupational health and safety management - St. Patrick, 17 Oct 2016, 3:45 PM - 5:00 PM

Background & Objectives

Evaluations of work disability programs are vital to improving and understanding the need, experience, impact and/or cost of the programs. The purpose of this review is to conduct a full paper review of a subsection of the included articles from a larger scoping review: the program evaluation of workers' compensation, return-to-work, sickness insurance systems and social assistant programs.

Methods

From the larger scoping review (which sorted 726 government-led work disability programs/policies articles published between 2000 and 2014 by program type and theme), additional data such as the type of evaluation (formative, process, efficacy, cost), primary outcome measures of interest (protocol, return-to-work, health/well-being, experience, etc.), and type of participants (client or program provider) were extracted through a full-text review of the relevant subsection of articles.

Results

Preliminary results identified 34 relevant articles that were program evaluations of work disability programs. Of these, over half of the studies were process evaluations, and almost a third were evaluations of efficacy; however, less than a fifth were cost analysis and formative evaluations. The most studied outcomes of interest were successful return-to-work, stakeholder experience, and the clients' health and well-being. Moreover, clients of the programs participated in about three quarters of the studies.

Conclusions

Eighty-five percent of the studies were either efficacy or process evaluations, leaving a gap for formative evaluations. This may reflect a publishing bias or a paucity of pre-program ‘homework’ to design programs. It is best practice for new programs or policies to undergo a formative assessment so that the gap being addressed by the program is identified. More studies should focus on including multiple stakeholders within the programs instead of solely the clients, as program providers may also identify valuable insight on the barriers and facilitators within the programs.

Scoping reviews examine the range and nature of research activity as well as identify research gaps in the existing literature. This scoping review allows researchers to gain a sense of the type of evaluations that have been completed in this field within the past fifteen years and gaps for future studies.