Abstract Details

Title: Collaborative development of a simple and valid leading indicators tool for occupational health & safety
Authors: Sara Macdonald; Benjamin Amick; Sheilah Hogg-Johnson; Lynda Robson
Session: Collaboration and advocacy as intervention approaches - St. Patrick, 17 Oct 2016, 2:10 PM - 3:10 PM

Background & Objectives

Leading indicators of occupational health and safety (OHS) are measures of OHS performance that can predict a firm’s workplace injury experience based on an assessment of its health and safety policies and practices.  An increasing interest in leading indicators of OHS has prompted decision makers in Ontario to seek valid and simple tools. The objectives of the research were to collaboratively develop a leading indicators questionnaire and industry benchmarks that could be used by workplace parties and consultants to assess and improve OHS performance.  

Methods

Health and safety associations (HSAs) and researchers in Ontario agreed upon an 8-item questionnaire of best practices in workplace health and safety. HSAs recruited firms to complete the questionnaire in multiple studies.  Organizations’ questionnaires scores were compared to their workers’ compensation claims and were aggregated and weighted to develop sector benchmarks. Worksite visits were conducted to test the questionnaire’s construct validity.

Results

The 8-item IWH-Organizational Performance Metric (IWH-OPM) was developed through a consensus-based process. Results of a study of 642 firms showed the OPM has acceptable internal consistency and that it is relevant to all organizations, regardless of industry or size. Results of a study of 325 firms suggests the tool is predictive of future OHS performance (as measured by claims rates). Case studies of five organizations showed the IWH-OPM has good construct validity (i.e. organizations with higher OPM scores also had the best OHS practices, generally, compared to those with lower scores.) Data from over 2000 firms completing the questionnaire were used to create benchmarks for 16 sectors. Workplace parties and OHS consultants are adopting the tool and benchmarks to identify gaps in OHS programs.

Conclusions

Researchers and occupational health and safety professionals developed a simple and valid leading indicator tool - the IWH-OPM that can be used to assess and improve OHS performance.  Researchers and HSAs have developed follow-up questions to help organizations improve low OPM scores and are building an application with gaming principles to improve leadership skills in OHS.