Background & Objectives Researchers have suggested that the effectiveness of worker health and safety representatives is closely tied to factors such as unionization, employment security and management orientation. While the identification of workplace factors can be useful, these kinds of findings tell us little about how the activities and strategies of representatives yield different outcomes and how these in turn relate to the different aspects of the employment context. Accordingly, this study examines the relationships between the self-reported activities and impacts of representatives and employment factors. Methods A non-random survey of 888 worker representatives was conducted via an on-line or hard copy survey instrument. Representatives were invited to participate in the survey through several on-line media (union and worker organization list serves and web sites), notices in health and safety publications, and through handouts and presentations at health and safety and union conferences. The survey was also administered in a paper form at the beginning of OHS certification and other training sessions offered by the Ontario Workers’ Health and Safety Centre. Follow-up interviews were conducted with 50 of the survey participants. Results A factor analysis identified two types of reported impacts (large-scale, small-scale) and two factor representative activities (information collection/worker mobilization and legally mandated OHS roles). Mixed multiple regression was then used to examine several models predicting to the two factor impact solutions with the two factor activity factor plus several other measures (unionization, use of temporary employees, rep. experience, time allowance, fear of layoffs, management cooperation, rep. gender) as independent variables. Precarity, gender, management responsiveness, hours of unpaid time, and workplace size are not significantly associated with overall impact scores. The major factors are spending more time doing info gathering/organizing (factor1) activities, followed by more paid time. Rep. experience also played a role. Overall the model explains a respectable amount of variation within and between economic sectors. The analysis also found that different combinations of factors were related to small and large impacts. Conclusions The findings support the argument that research emphasis should be placed on what worker representatives actually do to achieve change and explaining those differences rather than documenting workplace correlates of success.
|