Abstract Details

Title: Comparisons between 90 degree turn characteristics when using a head-mounted display versus 300 degree wrap around screens in a fixed-base driving simulator
Authors: Diego Gonzalez; Danielle Filio; Lynn Dony; Ryan Toxopeus; Michele Oliver
Session: Machinery operation at work: whole body vibration and beyond - Armoury, 17 Oct 2016, 3:45 PM - 5:00 PM

Background & Objectives

Driving simulators have been used to assess traffic safety and driving behaviour as well as to develop safer roads. Historically, wrap-around (WA) screens have been used in most driving simulators but recent advances in Head Mounted Display (HMD) technology may provide a space and cost saving alternative for car simulators. However, very little information is available comparing driving performances between the two display modalities. The objective of this work was to compare selected driving characteristics between HMD and WA displays.

Methods

After familiarization drives using both display modalities, participants (n=23; 21.7±3.1 years) performed two drives in a fixed-based full-scale-driving simulator (Oktal, Toulouse, France). Presented in a randomized order, one drive used six WA display screens providing a 300° field-of-view, and the other used the Oculus Rift™ DK2 (Oculus VR, CA, United States) HMD to view the simulated environment. Simulator data were collected through Oktal SCANeR™ Studio and analyzed using custom MATLAB code (The MathWorks Inc., MA, USA) for two right and two left 90° turns in each drive.

Results

ANOVAs (p≤0.05) revealed that HMD Velocity(Turn_Start), Velocity(Minimum) and Turn_Angle@Velocity(Minimum) were significantly lower than in the WA condition, whereas Turn_Angle@Velocity(Maximum) and Steering-Wheel-Angle(Maximum) were significantly higher than in the WA condition. During right turns, drivers had higher Velocity(Turn_Start) Velocity(Maximum), Velocity(Minimum), Velocity(Turn_Finish) as well as lower Steering-Wheel-Angle(Maximum). These values lead to significantly faster right Turn(Duration) times. For second trials of right and left turns, Velocity(Turn_Start), Steering-Wheel-Angle(Maximum), Turn_Angle@Velocity(Maximum), Velocity(Maximum) and Turn_Angle@Velocity(Minimum) were significantly higher than first turns.

Conclusions

Drivers using a HMD were more cautious when turning given the lower values for the various velocity variables and associated turn angles at which those values occurred. Right turns were taken quicker, possibly due to familiarization and incomplete stopping. Though all participants completed familiarization drives, the fact that the velocity variables increased during second turn occurences suggests that they became more familiarized as the experiment progressed. Result differences between the HMD with the WA display conditions strongly suggest that it may not be appropriate to use HMDs to quantify driving characteristics during turning. These differences probably result from the reduced field-of-view in the HMD (100°) over the WA.