Abstract Details

Title: Improving mental health support through co-worker education: A randomized parallel group trial
Authors: Sandra Moll; Scott Patten; Bonnie Kirsh; Heather Stuart; Joy MacDermid
Session: Issues on mental health and psychosocial conditions in the workplace - Colony Ballroom, 18 Oct 2016, 10:30 AM - 11:45 AM

Background & Objectives

Workplace mental health is a growing concern for employers due to the financial and human costs associated with high rates of absenteeism and presenteeism. Managers and co-workers can play a key role in early intervention and support for employees who are struggling with mental health issues, however they need training regarding when and how to act. The purpose of this study was to compare the impact of two workplace mental health training programs: “Beyond Silence”, an anti-stigma education program customized for healthcare employees, and “Mental Health First Aid”, a standardized, mental health literacy program.

Methods

A randomized parallel-group clinical trial was conducted with 215 healthcare employees in two multi-site healthcare organizations. Participants were randomly assigned to either the Beyond Silence program (six in-person plus five online sessions) or the Mental Health First Aid program (two full-day training sessions). The Beyond Silence program was led by peer educators who were employees with personal mental health experience that were trained to lead the program. Pre, post and three-month follow-up surveys were conducted to evaluate changes in mental health knowledge, beliefs and behaviors. An intent-to-treat analysis was conducted to compare the impact of the two programs.

Results

Differences were assessed using multi-level mixed models accounting for site, group and repeated measurement. Before-after comparisons showed significant changes across both programs, including increased mental health literacy, increased confidence in helping someone with a mental health issue issue, and decreased stigmatized beliefs. There did not appear to be a significant difference in outcomes across the two programs.  Changes appeared to be sustained over time, although sustained changes in stigmatized beliefs were more prominent in the Beyond Silence group. Qualitative data supported the value of contact-based education as a stigma-reduction strategy, and the value of creating a space for dialogue regarding issues unique to the context of healthcare work.

Conclusions

Study findings support the value of workplace mental health education for healthcare employees, and the importance of tracking not only changes in knowledge, but changes in attitudes and behaviors that will lead to early intervention and support for workers who may be struggling with mental health issues.