Abstract Details

Title: Managing safety in the context of operations: the effect of joint management system practices on safety and operational outcomes
Authors: Lynda Robson; Emile Tompa; Anna Sarnocinska-Hart; Robert Klassen; Anton Shevchenko; Sharvani Sharma; Sheilah Hogg-Johnson; Benjamin Amick; David Johnston; Anthony Veltri; Mark Pagell
Session: The Organizational level: disability and occupational health and safety management - St. Patrick, 17 Oct 2016, 3:45 PM - 5:00 PM

Background & Objectives

There has been little workplace-based OHS research that gives full consideration to the operational context. Yet it is of interest to know whether “best practices” in OHS and operations can co-exist or even enhance one another in terms of outcomes, or whether there is a trade-off. An earlier qualitative study established a relationship between the presence of a “joint management system” (JMS) and high performance in both OHS and operational outcomes. JMS was defined as a formal set of routines that allow for the shared planning, measurement, monitoring and continuous improvement of both operations and safety. The present study sought further understanding of the relationships between JMS and each of OHS and operational performance using quantitative methods.

Methods

Two types of data were collected from a sample of 200 Ontario manufacturing workplaces: i) survey data using respondent dyads of operational and OHS managers, ii) administrative data on workers’ compensation claims. Regression analyses were conducted with the key explanatory JMS variable having four categories derived from a cluster analysis of survey responses: JMS present (group 1), safety-weak JMS (group 2), operations-weak (group 3), and JMS absent (group 4). Separate regression models were estimated for each outcome measure. These included a summary operational performance measure based on assessments by the operational manager and six different injury claims-based measures derived from the workers’ compensation data.

Results

The primary finding was that workplaces with JMS practices performed better in both OHS and operations that workplaces without these practices. As well, the overall pattern of findings was consistent with OHS and operations being complementary with regards to performance, rather than synergistic or involving a trade-off.

Conclusions

JMS practices allow the achievement of high performance in both OHS and operations.