Background & Objectives Compensation rates for occupational cancer are generally poor in Canada and elsewhere. The possible exception is asbestos-related cancers, which are by far the most commonly compensated workplace cancer in Canada. This is particularly the case for mesothelioma, given that the only established cause is asbestos. However, there are a number of factors that potentially impact compensation, such as provincial policies, gender-based assumptions on causality by clinicians, and differential benefits for people diagnosed while of working age. In this paper we will investigate the impact of these factors on compensation for asbestos-related fatal mesotheliomas and lung cancers. Methods Estimated cases of asbestos-related cancer were generated by the Burden of Occupational Cancer Project. Only estimated fatal cancers in 2011, the reference year for the project, were used because compensation statistics were only available for fatalities. Numbers of compensated cases were provided by the Association of Workers Compensation Boards of Canada. Because compensation may lag behind diagnosis or death, the mean of the number of compensated cases 2011-2014 was divided by the number of estimated cancers in 2011 to calculate proportions. Only compensation rates in the four largest provinces were examined. Results The overall compensation rate for mesothelioma was 61%, with 64% for males versus 32% for females. The compensation rate also varied by age group; 46% for 20-54, 69% for 55-64, and 61% for 65 or older. British Columbia had the highest compensation rate (100%), followed by Quebec (67%), Ontario (61%), and Alberta (39%). Compensation rates for lung cancer were smaller. The overall rate for lung cancer was 5%, with 6% for males versus 2% for females. The rate also varied by age group; 2% for 20-54, 6% for 55-64, and 6% for 65 or older. There was less variability by province: Quebec (7%), followed by British Columbia (6%), Ontario (6%), and Alberta (2%). Conclusions The exact compensation rates presented here should only be regarded as an estimate because this was not a one-to-one matched process and year of diagnosis, or death, and compensation are not the same. However, the relative patterns here reveal major differences by gender, province, and age.
|