Abstract Details

Title: Measuring Success What measures can we use to evaluate MSD Interventions?
Authors: Nicolette Carlan
Session: Musculoskeletal Disabilities: Identification, Interventions, Incentives, Prevention - Armoury, 18 Oct 2016, 3:15 PM - 4:30 PM

Background & Objectives

MSDs develop over time, usually as a result of repetitive and continuous activity.  There is rarely an exact time which a worker can relate to the specific onset of the disability. The disability often extends over time without complete resolution.  For example tenosynovitis starts out slowly, becomes more disabling with activity and recedes when activity is reduced but is never completely resolved.

Notwithstanding the complex nature of MSDs we often measure the success of MSD interventions by a simple reduction in lost time claims (LTCs).  However reduction of LTCs also usually occurs over time and is not related in a linear fashion to the intervention.  So it is difficult to establish if the intervention was effective.  There is growing body of literature and experiences which indicate that there are other measures of effectiveness like improved productivity and employee retention to illustrate effectiveness. The objective of this presentation is to explore alternative metrics to be used to examine MSD intervention effectiveness.


Methods

This is second look at several MSD interventions and an examination of the effectiveness of interventions. Specifically what happened when CRE-MSD introduced a hydraulic ladder lift to maintenance workers and tools to reduce strain caused by crimping to plumbers? These findings are added to the conclusions in the literature that examine improvement of productivity and employee retention when there are ergonomic interventions.

Results

In the two CRE-MSD interventions identified we were able to document workers had MSD complaints attributable to their physical activities.  We could not, however, document lost time claims attributable to the activities. In follow-up discussions with labour and management we were advised that the interventions would not be continued because there was no evidence in a reduction of workers’ compensation costs. The literature looking at alternative metrics indicated that productivity and retention improved following the interventions and the interventions continued.

Conclusions

This retrospective review indicates that LTCs are not the only or best measure of effectiveness.  It also suggests that we need to understand the work environment and process to effectively understand the value of interventions.