Abstract Details

Title: Developing a Business Case for the Trucking Industry
Authors: Emile Tompa; Peter Vi
Session: Musculoskeletal Disabilities: Identification, Interventions, Incentives, Prevention - Armoury, 18 Oct 2016, 3:15 PM - 4:30 PM

Background & Objectives

Musculoskeletal disabilities (MSDs) may cause pain and discomfort but may not be sufficiently severe to result in time off work. A common metric to evaluate effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of an intervention in the occupational health and safety (OHS) literature is a reduction in lost-time claims (LTCs). However, a reduction of lost-time might not be the best indicator of a reduction of MSDs.  We propose an alternative way to assess the consequences of interventions for economic evaluation purposes which include not only monetary cost of health-related absences (sometime identified as productivity or human capital costs) but also health-related quality of life consequences that can be converted into monetary term.  Health-related quality of life may be a better way to capture the full range of health effects than the traditional human capital approach, which is narrowly focussed on labour-market earnings as a proxy for the value of health.

Methods

The traditional business case model has been applied to the case of the installation of ladder racks, a tool which has been shown to reduce physical risks, which can result in MSDs.  In the alternative analytic scenario we present an approach that includes estimates of a broader range of direct and indirect costs and consequences, including health-related quality of life impacts. 

 

Results

Injuries from installing ladders on the roof of a truck rarely result in lost-time claims.  Accordingly we were not able to establish a business case for the installation of hydraulic ladder racks, even though there was unanimity about the benefit of the tool. 

In another case, we examine the impacts of improved seating and the resultant reductions in vibration exposure for long-haul truck drivers. In both cases we explore more comprehensive valuations of intervention impacts to determine the economic value of the ergonomic intervention.


Conclusions

 Productivity and output impacts should not be the only valuations considered in OHS intervention studies. An important consideration is health-related quality of life. Limiting a business case to a reduction of LTCs may miss important impacts of the intervention. The inclusion of a broader range of impacts is critical to a full-fledge economic evaluation.