Background & Objectives Silica exposure continues to be a challenge in Canadian workplaces. Inherent to this is a lack of exposure data in high-risk industries. In the CAREX Canada project, the number of workers exposed to silica was previously estimated using the Canadian Workplace Exposures Database, European CAREX data, and peer-reviewed and grey literature. Exposure monitoring in the construction industry was generally lacking, and it is believed that exposures are not effectively controlled in this industry. In estimating exposure levels, CAREX Canada defaulted exposure levels into the “low” category when no data existed, and this likely underestimated exposure levels for silica in the under-sampled construction industry. The objective of this study was to compare and integrate CAREX Canada’s exposure level estimates for silica with an existing public database of silica exposure built from literature review to evaluate the potential for underestimation.
Methods CAREX Canada defined three exposure levels: 3 (low), 0.0125-0.025 mg/m3 (medium), and >0.025 mg/m3 (high). In order to be classified as high, for example, ≥20% of the samples for those workers had to be above the high threshold (0.025 mg/m3). If data did not exist for particular jobs, then the default was assigned as ‘low’. Data from the public database was compared to the CAREX level of exposure estimates in the same job categories to highlight inconsistencies in exposure levels. Results CAREX Canada consistently underestimated silica exposure levels in the construction industry. For example, CAREX Canada estimated that 10% of concrete finishers had low exposure, 90% had medium exposure, and none were classified as high exposure (based on available data). In contrast, the more recent and construction-focused database showed that 85% of samples taken among cement finishers were above the threshold used by CAREX Canada to indicate high exposure (0.025 mg/m3), far exceeding the standard of ≥20% of samples over the threshold. Exposure levels were similarly underestimated across construction occupations. Conclusions These results confirmed that CAREX Canada data underestimated silica exposure levels. The enhanced silica exposure level estimates will contribute to future cancer prevention activities by better identifying the highest exposed workers in the construction industry.
|